Home

Industry Answers: we undertook an analysis of customer service mistakes that phone companies make – key culprits of increasing churn and reduced loyalty

—

by

AnswerTeam
in

The Impact of Strategic Mistakes

While the modern mobile phone industry has been active and growing for over twenty years, looking at the level of customer service and satisfaction, there is a sense that something is missing in board room discussions.  Something is not being properly passed up to senior leadership, or senior executives have other priorities than to create a good service experience for their customers.

Mistakes in strategic leadership abound, and they have a direct impact not only on the customer experience, but also on employees.  Before we get into the core set of mistakes, let’s establish the importance of understanding how poor leadership in mobile phone companies can have a direct and material impact on operations and service.

Impact on Employees:

  • Stress and Frustration: Dealing with customer complaints about high prices, confusing bills, or lack of software support can be stressful for customer service representatives and sales staff. It can be difficult to defend practices they may not have control over. Is the organization really listening to these customer complaints beyond call center objectives to reduce volume and call time?  Is the organization seeking to leverage this information to create a better product?
  • Increased Workload: Confusing billing practices can lead to more customer inquiries, putting a strain on call centers and support teams. More than just stress and frustration, customer problems reduce efficiency and increase expenses.  Mobile phone companies have relentlessly increased the complexity of service to target niche audiences, thus creating an ever-confusing offer which lends itself to continual churn and low satisfaction.  Where is the customer voice in the marketing and operations?  From examples of companies like Apple, which dedicated their design and development to simplicity, can mobile phone companies take a page from this playbook and give consumers a comfortable experience?

Impact on Customers:

  • Financial Strain: Unexpected fees or a lack of budget-friendly options can strain customer finances. This situation then leads to…
  • Frustration and Anger: Confusing bills, limited software support, and poor customer service experiences can lead to customer frustration and anger. While the customer walks away with a mediocre sense of support, the lingering feeling is one of…
  • Feeling Devalued: Customers who feel pressured into expensive upgrades or left unsupported with older phones may feel the company doesn’t value them. Ultimately, customers know that they can easily switch service providers.  This frustration is then manifested in…
  • Brand Disloyalty: Negative experiences can lead customers to switch to carriers offering better value, clearer billing, and improved customer service.

Unhappy customers hurt the company’s bottom line, leading to pressure on employees, which in turn can create a negative customer service experience, and so on. By addressing these issues, mobile phone companies can create a win-win situation for both employees and customers.

Strategic Mistakes by Mobile Phone Companies

AnswerTeam has pulled together leading research, surveys and analytical pieces to compile a list of both strategic and operational mistakes that mobile phone companies have and continue to make with respect to their marketing campaigns, customer service, pricing plans and overall business model.

  • Prioritizing Flagships Over Value: The first among these mistakes brings to the fore a fundamental question of the value proposition.  Focusing heavily on high-end models with cutting-edge features neglects a large segment of budget-conscious buyers.
  • Limited Software Support: Stopping software updates and security patches for older phones frustrates users. With phones increasingly being used for personal and financial transactions, security is paramount.
  • Confusing Billing Practices: Opaque data plans, hidden fees, and unexpected charges damage customer trust. A lack of straightforward billing is probably the greatest and most enduring frustrations consumers have expressed over mobile phone plans over the years.  Studies also show that clear explanations over pricing and service is key to retaining customers who feel they are getting a fair deal.
  • Neglecting Customer Service: Long wait times, unhelpful representatives, and a lack of omnichannel support (phone, online chat, etc.) makes customers feel unheard and undervalued. Providing excellent customer service can help to build loyalty, but studies on this point are thin.  Few mobile companies manage to achieve this customer milestone.

Operational Mistakes by Mobile Phone Companies

The division between strategic and operational is a thin grey line, but what’s clear is that the strategic mistakes mentioned above manifest their impact in operational challenges which, collectively, contribute to customer angst.  Here are some of the major consumer annoyances that we unconvered.

  • Long Wait Times for Support:  Customers often experience long wait times when trying to reach customer support, whether via phone, chat, or email.  Long wait times clearly frustrate customers, making them feel undervalued and neglected. This leads to a perception that the company does not prioritize their needs, resulting in higher churn rates as customers seek more responsive providers.
  • Ineffective Problem Resolution:  Issues are not resolved effectively or require multiple contacts to fix a single problem.  So many times, even the mobile phone representative is not able to fix an issue nor provide a reasonable explanation.  Repeated failures to resolve issues can severely damage trust and satisfaction. Customers who must explain their problem multiple times or experience unresolved issues are more likely to switch to competitors.
  • Poor Communication Channels:  Limited or ineffective communication channels, such as lack of live chat support or cumbersome automated phone systems.  Customers prefer varied and accessible support options. Limited communication channels can lead to frustration and a sense that the company is hard to reach, pushing customers towards more accessible competitors.
  • Lack of Personalization: Treating all customers the same and not personalizing interactions based on customer history or preferences.  It is no surprise that customers begin to feel lost in an open sea of frustration. Brand loyalty suffers, and the mobile company loses any chance of making a long term connection.
  • Billing Issues:  Complicated billing processes and unresolved billing disputes.  Billing issues are a major pain point for customers (and to be sure, mobile phone companies who need to manage delinquent customers). If customers perceive that they are being overcharged or cannot easily resolve billing problems, premiumization opportunities for the carrier fall out the window.
  • Lack of Proactive Engagement:  Not engaging with customers proactively, and learning from the customer experience.  Proactive engagement shows that the company cares about the customer experience.
  • Complicated Cancellation Processes:  Making it difficult for customers to cancel services or plans.  Customers see right through this.  Mobile carriers think their cleverness of making cancellation difficult carries a net benefit.  This short-term thinking couldn’t be farther from the truth.  Complicated cancellation processes only frustrate customers and leave a negative last impression. This not only increases churn but also generates negative word-of-mouth, damaging the company’s reputation.

What must mobile companies do to improve customer relations?

To improve customer service, mobile phone companies can implement a variety of strategies aimed at enhancing the customer experience. Here are several examples of measures that have been undertaken by mobile companies globally.

Investment in genuine service

  • Reduce Wait Times:  Invest in advanced call center technologies and optimize staffing schedules based on peak times.  Example: Verizon introduced a virtual hold feature that allows customers to receive a call back rather than waiting on hold, reducing perceived wait times.
  • Better Training:  Train customer service representatives thoroughly and empower them to make decisions. Example: Sprint empowered its front-line agents to resolve billing issues without needing supervisor approval, leading to quicker resolutions.
  • Track Complaints:  Implement a robust complaint management system and train staff in empathy and effective problem-solving.  Example: O2 UK has a specialized complaints team trained to handle escalated issues, ensuring complaints are resolved satisfactorily.
  • Leverage Customer Feedback:  Actively solicit and act on customer feedback to continually improve services.  Example: Verizon collects feedback through regular surveys and uses the data to make targeted improvements in customer service operations.

Rationalize the personal side of business

  • Personalize Customer Interactions:  Use customer data to tailor interactions and recommendations.  Example: T-Mobile employs a customer relationship management (CRM) system that provides representatives with detailed customer profiles, enabling more personalized service.  Also, companies can offer multiple contact options including live chat, social media support, and in-app messaging.  Example: Vodafone provides 24/7 customer support via live chat and has a dedicated team for social media inquiries, making it easier for customers to get help.
  • Empower Customer Service Representatives:  Provide comprehensive training and grant more authority to resolve issues on the spot.  Example:  EE in the UK provides extensive training for its customer service teams and empowers them to make goodwill gestures, such as bill credits, without needing managerial approval.
  • Balance Automation and Human Interaction:  Use automation for simple tasks and ensure easy access to human agents for complex issues.  Example: AT&T’s automated systems handle routine inquiries, but customers can quickly opt to speak to a live representative for more complex problems.
  • Follow Up with Customers:  Implement a follow-up protocol after resolving issues to ensure customer satisfaction.  Example: T-Mobile sends follow-up surveys and calls customers after resolving their issues to ensure they are satisfied with the resolution.

Improve transparency and build trust

  • Ensure Consistent Information:  Solution: Implement a centralized knowledge base accessible to all customer service representatives.  Example: AT&T developed an internal wiki that is regularly updated, ensuring all agents provide the same accurate information to customers.
  • Simplify:  billing, terms and conditions must be simplified, while making , processes for cancellations and returns transparent.  Example: T-Mobile’s “Un-carrier” initiative simplified pricing and removed contracts, making it easier for customers to understand their plans and make changes without hassle.
  • Conclusion

While these examples show ways in which mobile companies are applying creative solutions to solve known problems, the underlying analysis shows that in effect, through poor top-down strategic decisions and without a holistic prioritization of customer service, the problems that mobile phone companies are aiming to solve are the problems of their own making.

To be sure, adopting these strategies can help mobile carriers enhance their customer service, leading to increased customer satisfaction and loyalty with reduced churn rates over time.  The next big challenge in the evolution and maturation of the mobile phone market is to undo the fundamental mistakes of strategy and move toward a truly customer-centric mindset.